Philadelphia Skyline

Blog Feed

contact

Call Us For A Free Consultation (267) 350-6600

We have offices in Philadelphia, Allentown, Holland, Lancaster, & Reading

Pennsylvania Health Insurance Rates Are Soaring: Are Insurers Acting in Bad Faith?

Rising health insurance rates do not, by themselves, prove that an insurer is acting in bad faith. But if an insurer charges higher premiums while improperly denying or mishandling a covered claim, the way it handles that claim may raise a separate legal issue. Contact HGSK Injury Lawyers if you’re in the middle of an insurance dispute. Our bad faith insurance lawyers in Lancaster can assess your policy, denial, insurer communications, and medical records to determine whether the dispute is a routine coverage issue or something more serious.

What’s the Reason for the Increase in Health Insurance Rates?

Pennsylvania’s recent rate increases have multiple causes. The enhanced federal premium tax credits that helped lower marketplace premiums expired at the end of 2025, which raised costs for many Pennie enrollees.

The 2027 rate increase is a separate issue. Insurers initially requested an average 17.14% increase for individual-market plans. After reviewing those requests, the Pennsylvania Insurance Department approved an average 15.97% increase and denied $94.7 million in proposed increases it found unjustified. The Department pointed to rising medical and prescription drug costs and federal changes to health care funding as factors affecting rates.

The statewide average does not tell the whole story. Actual premiums vary by plan, location, household income, family size, and other factors. A higher premium also does not give an insurer permission to deny claims or disregard the terms of its policies.

Can Higher Insurance Rates Prove Bad Faith?

No. A higher premium does not prove that an insurer acted in bad faith. Pennsylvania’s bad faith law focuses on how an insurer handled a claim under a policy, not on what the company charged for coverage. Under 42 Pa.C.S. § 8371, a court can award interest, punitive damages, and attorney fees and costs when an insurer is found to have acted in bad faith toward a policyholder.

A bad faith claim requires more than showing that an insurer denied a claim or made a decision you disagree with. The evidence must show that the insurer lacked a reasonable basis for its decision and knew of or recklessly disregarded that lack of a reasonable basis.

The type of health plan also matters. Many employer-sponsored health plans are governed by a federal law, the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA), which generally prevents Pennsylvania bad faith claims against those plans. ERISA has its own appeal process and remedies. Plans purchased individually, including through Pennie, are generally not subject to ERISA, so state law may apply.

What Should a Lancaster Policyholder Look for After a Denial?

Start with the insurer’s explanation. Review the denial letter, relevant policy provisions, medical records, and communications with the insurance company. A denial may deserve further review if the insurer appears to have ignored important medical information, relied on facts that don’t support its decision, or failed to give a reasonable explanation for its decision. Those signs don’t automatically prove bad faith, but they can justify a closer review of the claim.

What If Your Health Insurer Denies Treatment in Lancaster?

Keep copies of the denial, policy, medical records, bills, and communications with the insurer. You may also have appeal or independent review rights, depending on the type of coverage involved. Our Lancaster bad faith insurance attorneys can review the denial and medical records, assess available review or appeal options, and determine whether the insurer’s decision warrants further legal action.

Pennsylvania’s Insurance Department reported in 2026 that its Independent External Review program had overturned about 48% of eligible claims submitted since 2024. That figure doesn’t mean every denied claim will be overturned. However, it shows that some disputed coverage decisions yield different results after independent review.

Don’t Let a Higher Premium Be the End of the Conversation. Speak With Our Lancaster Bad Faith Insurance Attorneys

Paying more for health insurance doesn’t automatically create a bad-faith claim. However, a higher premium also doesn’t prevent you from questioning a denial or claim-handling decision that conflicts with your policy or the available evidence. If you are facing an insurance dispute, reach out to HGSK Injury Lawyers. Talk to our bad-faith insurance lawyers in Lancaster at no charge about your situation by scheduling an appointment online or by calling 267-551-8782.